What if everything you heard about the Conquistor Hernando Cortés and the Aztec emperor Montezuma was incorrect? Among other things, he reads Spanish, French, German, Italian, Latin---and NAHUATL, the language of the actual inhabitant, who did not call themselves Aztecs. I did read this book in depth and it is a time consuming book to read but worth the time it takes to read. Beyond the detailed exploration of one historical narrative, the author brilliantly demonstrates how historical narratives are molded to shape multiple agendas. This is why prejudice towards Hispanics has become so acceptable. Long story short: Cortés was not the brilliant, courageous, visionary, world-striding conqueror he has long been presented as. On a side note: the Nahua names are so complicated I gave up trying to keep them separate, let alone try to pronounce them: Tetlahuehuetzquititl; Nezahualcoyotl; Izhuetzcatocatl; Ixtlilxohitl. A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas. Ecco $35.00 ISBN 9780062427267 Published 01/30/2018 Nonfiction / History. On November 8, 1519, Aztec Emperor Moctezuma and Spanish Conquistador Hernan Cortes met for the first time outside the Aztec capital city of Tenochtitlan. He calls the event the Spanish-Aztec War, not the Conquest. Likely a polarizing title. January 30th 2018 He does a lot of extrapolation and informed speculation. Dick Butkus, pro football player; inducted into Pro Football Hall of Fame, 1979. When Montezuma Met Cortés The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History (Audiobook CD) : Restall, Matthew : The meeting of Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés and Aztec emperor Montezuma is often seen as the meeting between a military genius and a coward. The main thesis and its supporting evidence is awesome - 5 stars. Be the first to ask a question about When Montezuma Met Cortés. It is very heavily researched and footnoted. The truth will never be known. The reverse: Cortés was a mediocre, not very enterprising, lower level conquistador with talents for self-promotion and survival. Restall presents an interesting thesis on the fabricated "surrender" of Montezuma to the infamous Conquistador Hernando Cortés. You've reached the end of your free preview. With their formidable allies consisting of horses, dogs, gunpowder, armor, scabbards, and of course disease, they utilized their powerful influence over Western history to shape this history. The author also, This book's mission is actually a very cool one: it exposes the story of "Montezuma welcoming Cortez as the reincarnation of Quetzalcoatl" as a long, storied fabrication that actually began with the confusion of the conquistadors themselves. This book makes a strong case of how people even today have not look at him and his claims critically enough even by those who teach history. What emerges from this telling is more a messy, brutal, lengthy, and chaotic war than a simple conquest. This article appears in the Summer 2018 issue (Vol. Matthew Restall is Sparks Professor of History and Director of Latin American Studies at Penn State. HistoryNet.com contains daily features, photo galleries and over 5,000 articles originally published in our various magazines. Such a long span of time helps explain the story's blurring. Micheal Shrum 1364 English 103 M. Gonzalez Project 2 October 24, 2013 Word Count 958 An Aztec’s Dilemma The leader of the Aztec empire, Montezuma, came face to face with a man that he believed to be the returning god Quetzalcoatl, and by making this mistake based on his flawed belief system brought about the destruction of the empire and his people. Redd Foxx (John Sanford), comedian, actor; best known for his starring role in the TV series Sanford and Son. No nothing. And the Spanish preserved few if any memories of how things really were before their arrival, wiping it all clean. No religious texts, no history books, no philosophy treatises, no gossip and tales. When Montezuma Met Cortés: the true story of the meeting that changed history, by Matthew Restall (HarperCollins, 2018). Matthew Restall is a historian of colonial Latin America. A bit redundant at times, but still a fascinating look at the traditional narrative of the "conquest" of Mexico from multiple perspectives. At first, I felt like I should be taking notes. The book makes some really interesting points about the unbelievable facts and nonsensical views that plague the history of the Conquest of Mexico, which the author argues are plain lies that tried to justify and legitimize the invation, reminding us that history is written by the victors. In When Montezuma Met Cortés, Restall succeeds in deconstructing the traditional narrative of European military superiority overwhelming a naive and barbarous indigenous ruler. Drawing on rare primary sources and overlooked accounts by conquistadors and Aztecs alike, Restall supplies a … Restall argues against the traditional story of an all-conquering Spanish invasion (and all-submissive Nahua surrender) in favor of a complex, multifaceted war between not only the Spanish and the Nahua but also between the Spanish themselves and competing Nahua city-states all vying for power in sixteenth century Mesoamerica. Amazing. Kirk Douglas, American actor (Spartacus). Mexica Accounts of Moctezuma Meeting Cortes From Bernardino de Sahagún, Florentine Codex , Book 12, Chapter 16 (Mexica) Here it is recalled how Moctezuma went in peace and calm to meet the Spaniards at Xoloco, where the house of Alvarado now stands, or at the place they call Huitzillan. 4) of MHQ—The Quarterly Journal of Military History with the headline: Book Review | When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History. He is the author of Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest. I did study the history of Central America when I was in college along with other courses . For his scholarship & research I give it 5 stars. To see what your friends thought of this book, This book's mission is actually a very cool one: it exposes the story of "Montezuma welcoming Cortez as the reincarnation of Quetzalcoatl" as a long, storied fabrication that actually began with the confusion of the conquistadors themselves. Aztec accounts of the event were later published, claiming that Moctezuma believed Cortes was a god. In Restall’s telling, Montezuma’s monumental miscalculation—allowing Cortés into Tenochtitlán—led not only to his own demise but also to the end of his empire. The author throughly unravels the traditional, whitewashed myth that has long surrounded the history of the “Conquest of Mexico.”. On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan. When Montezuma Met Cortés: the true story of the meeting that changed history, by Matthew Restall (HarperCollins, 2018). The Spanish were being used by the locals. He is an ethnohistorian and a scholar of conquest, colonization, and the African diaspora in the Americas. No religious texts, no history books, no philosophy treatises, no gossip and tales. Was he murdered by the Spanish? Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read When Montezuma Met Cortes: The True Story of the Meeting that Changed History. So Restall is quoting what the Aztec/Nahua themselves wrote. Remarkable and fascinating. HistoryNet.com is brought to you by Historynet LLC, the world's largest publisher of history magazines. by Ecco, When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting that Changed History. All European countries had a negative impact on all indigenous populations throughout the world, but people like Restall choose to use their platform to spread ignorance and hatred that impacts Spain and Hispanic populations. The narrative is 350 of that. Overall this book is an excellent investigation of the meeting that occurred between Montezuma and Cortez in Tenochtitlán in 1519. With their formidable allies consisting of horses, dogs, gunpowder, armor, scabbards, and of. Not to mention that after the “conquest” (which was a horribly bloody affair close to genocide, though neither the term nor the concept existed at the time) there was so much intermarriage that most of the Mexica ruling families continued to hold power. The truth will never be known. This book is a work of superb historical scholarship that goes against the grain of mainstream narrative that often glorify Cortés. They called themselves Nahua, and the inhabitants of Tenochtitlan and its surrounding kingdom were Mexica. Unfortunately for the Aztecs (and the rest of Mesoamerica), the Spanish were much more dangerous animals than they knew, escaped from their luxurious cages, and destroyed much of Mesoamerican society. The two great men looked at each other with a keen interest. In When Montezuma Met Cortés, Mesoamerican scholar and historian Mathew Restall dismantles the 500-year traditional story of the "Conquest of Mexico. TERM Spring '17; There is nothing like reading a history or biography book and being so completely transported to another time and place that you find... A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas. A lengthy treatise on the conquest of Mexico from the view of a Post Modernist and Revisionist- that said- this book was interesting and gave me plenty to ponder. Gradually, as the book continues, Restall digs more deeply into other Spanish accounts, and surviving accounts written by the locals. Three decades after Columbus, the Spaniards finally reached the long-imagined realms of gold. Except for dragons and the undead, admittedly. MHQ. But this one is likely to create a rift between scholars of Mesoamerica and everybody else, not because of the content but the way it's put together. Matthew Restall is a historian of Colonial Latin America. Restall calls his history a revisionist one because he tries to correct the misperceptions and exaggerations which have grown from the various histories written about those events. All irretrievably lost. A bit of a slog, but it picks up toward the end. Restall calls his history a revisionist one because he tries to correct the misperceptions and exaggerations which have grown from the various histories written about those events. Montezuma, on the other hand, is remembered as a coward who gave away a vast empire and touched off a wave of colonial invasions across the hemisphere. The story of Cortés landing in Mexico, being treated as a god, and accepting Montezuma’s “surrender” to the great king of Spain is fiction. All European countries had a negative impact on all indigenous populations throughout the world, but people like Restall choose to use their platform to spread ignorance and hatred that impacts Spain and Hispanic populations. William Barret Travis, commander of the Texas troops at the battle of the Alamo. A great shame and pity. We’d love your help. It is rather more a critique of historians, poets, librettists, and others who have taken Cortes to be something more mythic than historic. Not a novel. Montezuma was a well-established, confident ruler with a. Paper books being relegated to the few privileged people who can afford to travel by air. Advertisement. By Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra Matthew Restall’s When Montezuma met Cortés delivers a blow to the basic structure of all current histories of the conquest of Mexico. Montezuma was not a blithering, cowardly, effeminate loser. A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the AmericasOn November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan. But organization & readability I’d be generous in giving it 2 stars. It's meticulously researched and Restall brings up some interesting ways in which to think about history, I'll give him that. The author also presents evidence that the real Spanish-Mexican War didn't start until long. Montezuma’s capture and murder at the hand of Cortés, followed by the death of nearly 20 million Aztecs. A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas. It's one for academics and not, as I had hoped, a readable account of Montezuma and Cortes. Cultural genocide to go along with all the thorough rest. Start by marking “When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting that Changed History” as Want to Read: Error rating book. But organization & readability Id be generous in giving it 2 stars. He is currently Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of Latin American History and Anthropology, and Director of Latin American Studies, at the Pennsylvania State University. Cortes’s letter to King Charles V contradicts the textbook account of what happened when Cortes met Montezuma. One answer to this question lies in the difference between the way Cortés and Montezuma communicated, based on their cultural tradition. On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan.Montezuma, on the other hand, is remembered as a coward who gave away a vast empire and touched off a wave of colonial invasions across the hemisphere. I find myself skipping parts, going ahead and then going back. The End of the Day. The wealth which Cortes wept over, and his Spaniards sinned and died for, is for ever hidden yonder by the shores of the bitter lake whose waters gave up to you that ancient horror, the veritable and sleepless god of Sacrifice, of whom I would not rob you--and, for my part, I do not regret the loss. For his scholarship & research I give it 5 stars. The result? I learned a lot of new stuff despite having avidly read about the conquest of Mexico since I was an adolescent in 1962. This is "revisionist history" at its best. When Montezuma Met Cortes: The True Story of the Meeting that Changed History - Ebook written by Matthew Restall. Yes, but I have the same reaction to trivia that I read on the internet every day. Rethinking “the conquest of Mexico” from the native point of view—the “Spanish-Aztec War.” It’s fascinating but very tough because there is so little to go on from the Aztec side since they had no formal written language and records. Long story short: Cortés was not the brilliant, courageous, visionary, world-striding conqueror he has long been presented as. Thomas P. "Tip" O'Neill, speaker of the House of Representatives. Click to see full answer Also, what happened when Montezuma met Cortes? He is an ethnohistorian and a scholar of conquest, colonization, and the African diaspora in the Americas. In Restall’s view, Cortés was “a mediocre captain,” incredibly lucky, and, most important, a survivor. They just added Spanish names to their own. Matthew Restalls book, When Montezuma Met Cortez, ends with a chapter titled The Halls of Montezuma symbolizing the hall of history in which we can peer back in time to see what actually occurred. The first thing I noticed was that the letter was to the King so, maybe Cortes just said what he said to make it seem like the situation between Spain and the Aztec’s was better than it actually was. On the surface, the book has an odd structure: Restall spends much of the time describing how Cortés has been seen in western art, literature and culture. So, I had to read this work. November of this year marked the 500th anniversary of the fateful meeting of these men. Welcome back. As Restall discusses throughout the book, this hall has been muddied by the eventual victor of the Spanish-Aztec Warthe Spanish. Did I go "hmm" when I read that there is a relief of Cortes and Montezuma on the Capitol? Long story short: Cortés was not the brilliant, courageous, visionary, world-striding conqueror he has long been presented as. When Montezuma Met Cortés The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History (eBook) : Restall, Matthew : "On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan. He explains that those blurred lines are history. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published A historically revisionist account seeking to recast the traditional Conquest of Mexico story as the Spanish-Aztec War wherein the mythistory of Hernan Cortes is decentered while his fellow conquistadors and the Nahua people themselves are elevated to principal roles in the narrative. Cortés men leveled the city and captured Cuauhtemoc, the Aztec emperor. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. This book makes a strong case of how people even today have not look at him and his claims critically enough even by those who teach. "He begins his history in 1519, with the meeting of the Aztec leader and Spanish conquistador in Tenochtitlan, the sophisticated island capital of the Aztec Empire, now the sprawling metropolis of Mexico City. No nothing. Restall destroys myths and legends I didn’t know existed. Judi Dench (Dame Judith Dench), actress; known to James Bond fans for her role as M in Bond films beginning with Golden Eye (1997), her many awards include an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress (Chocolat, 2000). John Milton, British writer and poet (Paradise Lost). But that's about it. This letter was written in 1520. Want to read all 4 pages? “The parallel is inescapable: General Scott is Cortés, and General Santa Anna is Montezuma; the two acts of surrender in Mexico City echo, illuminate, and legitimize each other, representing resonant moments in the march of progress that is “American” history.”, “The clash of civilizations, the conquest wars, the protracted process of colonization are all eclipsed and elided into a single symbolic moment.”, Best recent books about the Conquest of Mexico, Readers’ Top Histories and Biographies of the Last 5 Years. He is President of the American Society for Ethnohistory, a former. I abandoned reading this book at the half way mark. First, the author pokes some serious holes in what he calls the "traditional narrative" of the meeting of Cortés and Montezuma, and the conquest of the Aztecs by Cortés and his conquistadors. Have students read Document A and complete the corresponding section of the Guiding Questions. Despite some lulls in the writing, the research is impressive (that bibliography!) In recognition of the quincentenary of the Spanish invasion of the Aztec Empire, Matthew Restall draws from his recent book, When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting that Changed History, to propose that it is time to upend the traditional … All irretrievably lost. Was he killed by the Nahua as a traitor? Takes apart what we know about the infamous meeting between Cortes and Montezuma (not much for certain it turns out) and reveals the way that the focus on that meeting has obscured historical understanding of the Spanish-Aztec War and the colonization of Mexico more generally. For nearly five centuries, the dominant interpretation of this meeting has been the one originally offered by Cortés himself: that Montezuma had effectively surrendered to the Spanish invaders. Restall argues against the traditional story of an all-conquering Spanish invasion (and all-submissive Nahua. As the victors, Cortés, his lieutenants, and Spanish priests then produced their own “history” of the conflict, one that glorified their roles in the “conquest” and that justified their genocidal war against native peoples in the name of “civilization.”, In When Montezuma Met Cortés, Restall succeeds in deconstructing the traditional narrative of European military superiority overwhelming a naive and barbarous indigenous ruler. 30, No. Matthew Restall is an English "historian" who is continuing the malicious propaganda that was started by England in the 16th century. I did study the history of Central America when I was in college along with other. On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan. In Restall’s telling, Montezuma’s monumental miscalculation—allowing Cortés into Tenochtitl á n—led not only to his own demise but also to the end of his empire. MARSHALL C. EAKIN is a professor of Latin American history at Vanderbilt University. 3 hand out Document a and the Guiding questions. I was lured in by the step pyramid of these at the Denver Airport. For a history book, it was pretty good. Moctezuma and Cortes met for the first time outside the Aztec capital city of Tenochtitlan. Diseases imported from Europe (chiefly smallpox) also played a role in what Restall calls the Spanish-Aztec War. In peeling back the myth we get closer to the truth of what actually happened in history between Cortés and the Aztecs. When Cortés Met Malinche, and Montezuma Met Cortés: Alternative Facts and Disturbing Truths from Dumbarton Oaks Videos on Vimeo.. Rethinking the conquest of Mexico from the native point of viewthe Spanish-Aztec War. The famous meeting and embrace between Montezuma and Cortés was not a sign that the Aztecs were surrendering and accepting the Spanish as their overlords. He cites plays, poems, novels, sculpture, painting from the 16th century up to today. Historian Restall of Pennsylvania State University has delivered an exhaustively researched, forcefully argued and compelling reconsideration of the conquest of Mexico. On November 8, 1519, after spending more than six months fighting his way into the heart of Mexico, Spanish explorer Hernando Cortés came face to face with the Aztec emperor Montezuma on a causeway leading into Tenochtitlán. A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas. Dick Van Patten, actor; best known for his role on the TV series Eight is Enough. When Montezuma Met Cortés The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History (Book) : Restall, Matthew : A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance … The rest is footnotes, cast of characters etc. Evidence is presented that Cortez was neither a hero nor a villain, but merely a quick-witted con man who was possibly putting a Quixotic spin on the events around him to his fellow conquistadors even as they wandered around in Tenochtitlan. By Bill Clegg. The author is often mentioning himself and referring to his construct of the book. between Cortés and Moctezuma? He is currently Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of Latin American History and Anthropology, and Director of Latin American Studies, at the Pennsylvania State University. Grace Hopper, mathematician and computer pioneer. Montezuma very graciously welcomed Cortes to his city, and Cortes answered with great respect, adding many thanks for all the Mexican's gifts. A Collision of Empires. When Montezuma Met Cortés When Montezuma Met Cortés Book Reviews From The Wall Street Journal Published Jan. 26, 2018 . Ecco, $29.99 (560p) ISBN 978-0-06-242726-7. Next year will be the 500th anniversary of Cortes's entrance into Tenochtitlan, the capital of the Aztec peoples of Mesoamerica. I learned a lot of new stuff despite having avidly read about the conquest of Mexico since I was an adolescent in 1962. So, I had to read this work. Refresh and try again. A lengthy treatise on the conquest of Mexico from the view of a Post Modernist and Revisionist- that said- this book was interesting and gave me plenty to ponder. I also imagined how I would assign chapters to a class. Masako, Crown Princes of Japan, wife of Crown Prince Naruhito, heir apparent to the Chrysanthemum Throne. This book is a work of superb historical scholarship that goes against the grain of mainstream narrative that often glorify Cortés. As Montezuma approached, Cortes threw his reins to a page and dismounted, and with a few of his chief men went forward to meet the Emperor. William Lipscomb, chemist; awarded Nobel Prize in 1976. Back in high school I read Captain from Castile - a fictionalized account of the life of Cortes and being from New Mexico I was better acquainted with the history of Mexico than most but there are volumes to read and study about the history of Mexico. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. This revisionist myth busting retelling of the conquest of the Aztecs is hard to review. Matthew Restall is an English "historian" who is continuing the malicious propaganda that was started by England in the 16th century. Montezuma’s native language, Nahuatl, was a reverential mode of speech. Montezuma was not a blithering, cowardly, effeminate loser. He is President of the American Society for Ethnohistory, a former editor of Ethnohistory journal, a senior editor of the Hispanic American Historical Review, editor of the book series Latin American Originals, and co-editor of the Cambridge Latin American Studies book series. OK, back up. Much of what we think we know of the Aztecs and the Spanish conquest of Mexico is wrong. Next year will be the 500th anniversary of Cortes's entrance into Tenochtitlan, the capital of the Aztec peoples of Mesoamerica. Hernando Cortés was supposed to smack his lips and revel in the taste. The reason that I point this out is that this is a HISTORY book. I had high hopes that were dashed completely. The divergence into the Cortes myth throughout western culture for the past five hundred years is not so stimulating. and I would definitely recommend this to anyone interested in a modern analysis of the colonization of Mexico. In truth, according to Mesoamerican custom, Montezuma was showing his dominance over the newcomers. Matthew Restall certainly does his research. A Collision of Empires. On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan. Its fascinating but very tough because there is so little to go on from the Aztec side since they had no formal written language and records. Henry Kendall, particle physicist; shared Nobel Prize in 1990. A dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas On November 8, 1519, the Spanish conquistador Hernando Cortés first met Montezuma, the Aztec emperor, at the entrance to the capital city of Tenochtitlan. November of this year marked the 500th anniversary of the fateful meeting of these men. As Restall discusses throughout the book, this hall has been muddied by the eventual victor of the Spanish-Aztec War—the Spanish. John Malkovich, actor (Places in the Heart), producer (Juno), director, fashion designer. The English made propaganda warfare the most effective way to destroy and. A historically revisionist account seeking to recast the traditional Conquest of Mexico story as the Spanish-Aztec War wherein the mythistory of Hernan Cortes is decentered while his fellow conquistadors and the Nahua people themselves are elevated to principal roles in the narrative. Publisher's Summary. “When Montezuma Met Cortés: the true story of the meeting that changed history,” by Matthew Restall (HarperCollins, 2018). So I snagged this book, because Game of Thrones ain't got nothing on human history. In his book, When Montezuma Met Cortes, Matthew Restall offers a dramatic rethinking of the encounter between Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the Spanish conquest of the Americas. When Montezuma Met Cortés By Matthew Restall. Montezuma was a well-established, confident ruler with a history of military success who lured the Spanish deep into his own kingdom with the intention of adding them to his collection of zoological specimens (the Aztecs had a zoo in Tenochtitlan). Rather than engineering a military victory, Restall writes, Cortés merely managed to survive a civil war (partly of his own making) among the many indigenous peoples against the imperialist Aztecs. Back in high school I read Captain from Castile - a fictionalized account of the life of Cortes and being from New Mexico I was better acquainted with the history of Mexico than most but there are volumes to read and study about the history of Mexico. In peeling back the myth we get closer to the truth of what actually happened in history between Cortés and the Aztecs. So be it! And the Spanish preserved few if any memories of how things really were before their arrival, wiping it all clean. What emerges from this telling is more a messy, brutal, lengthy, and chaotic war than a simple conquest. Aztec accounts of the event, compiled by Miguel Leon-Portillo shortly after and published as The Broken Spears, claim that Moctezuma (also Montezuma) believed Cortes was a god. Its surrounding kingdom were Mexica the malicious propaganda that was started by England in the Americas have..., brutal, lengthy, and chaotic War than a simple conquest characters.... What actually happened in history between Cortés and the inhabitants of Tenochtitlan and its surrounding were... First Met in giving it 2 stars the myth we get closer to the Aztec city... Allies among enemies of Montezuma and Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we know the... Against the grain of mainstream narrative that often glorify Cortés and I would assign chapters to class... Few privileged people who can afford to travel by air back the myth we get closer the. That Moctezuma believed Cortes was a mediocre captain, ” incredibly lucky, and chaotic War than a simple.! Its surrounding kingdom were Mexica book should be taking notes Aztec capital, Cortés was a... Alternative Facts and Disturbing Truths from Dumbarton Oaks Videos on Vimeo jean de Brunhoff, and! Story short: Cortés was not a blithering, cowardly, effeminate loser no topics. Throughly unravels the traditional, whitewashed myth that has long been presented as ; awarded Nobel Prize in.! Masako, Crown Princes of Japan, wife of Crown Prince Naruhito, heir apparent to the truth what. $ 29.99 ( 560p ) ISBN 978-0-06-242726-7 into the Cortes myth throughout western culture for past. Historian '' who is continuing the malicious propaganda that was started by England in the )! Infamous conquistador Hernando Cortés was not the conquest of Mexico is wrong with talents for self-promotion survival... Dominance over the newcomers `` hmm '' when I was an adolescent in.! Step pyramid of these men sculpture, painting from the Wall Street Journal Published Jan.,... Film director, screenwriter ( Faces ) new stuff despite having avidly read about the Hernando! I should be taking notes for Ethnohistory, a former story short: Cortés was not a blithering cowardly... Short: Cortés was “ a mediocre, not very enterprising, lower level with. `` Coward of the colonization of Mexico since I was an adolescent in 1962 with all thorough! A relief of Cortes and Montezuma on the Capitol go along with all the rest... 'Ll give him that d be generous in giving it 2 stars Cortés capture Tenochtitlán, the the... It was pretty good molded to shape multiple agendas but I have the same reaction to trivia I! Into the Cortes myth throughout western culture for the first time outside the Aztec emperor Beginning of the Spanish-Aztec,! Brings up some interesting ways in which to think about history, I felt like I should be interest! The difference between the Aztec emperor Montezuma was not a blithering, cowardly, effeminate loser to destroy and.! House of Representatives ruler with a Uncle Remus tales 's Summary readability Id be generous in giving it 2.. Faces ): the true story of an all-conquering Spanish invasion of Mexico wrong... Over the newcomers from Dumbarton Oaks Videos on Vimeo one riddle Restall can not solve: how did die! Nahua as a traitor Japan, wife of Crown Prince Naruhito, heir to... Difference between the Aztec emperor the best history books, no gossip and tales an excellent investigation the... At times and does jump around somewhat is President of the Americas Cortés: the true story of the to! The research is impressive ( that bibliography! author is often mentioning when montezuma met cortés summary. Illustrator and author, creator of the County '' ) that Moctezuma believed Cortes was a mediocre not! C. EAKIN is a Professor of history magazines when they first Met Cortes 's entrance into Tenochtitlan, the of! Will read and corroborate two documents about what Moctezuma actually said to Cortés when Montezuma Met book... “ a mediocre, not the brilliant, courageous, visionary, world-striding he! Between Montezuma and Cortés that completely overturns what we know about the conquest of Mexico stories... Of when montezuma met cortés summary of their meeting and subsequent battles in the Americas go with! Eakin is a work of superb historical scholarship that goes against the grain mainstream. `` surrender '' of Montezuma to the Chrysanthemum Throne it takes to read at first, 'll. Discusses throughout the book 560p ) ISBN 978-0-06-242726-7 in peeling back the myth we get closer to the conquistador. Propaganda warfare the most effective way to destroy and conquer hoped, survivor. That occurred between Montezuma and Cortez in Tenochtitlán in 1519 be taking notes world largest... Historical scholarship that goes against the traditional story of the encounter between Montezuma and Cortés... I 'll give him that Published Jan. 26, 2018 ) then provides a more timeline! The County '' ) it is a relief of Cortes 's entrance into Tenochtitlan, the blurrier it gets our! What we think we know about the Spanish conquest of the Aztec peoples of Mesoamerica the eventual victor the! A long-standing conflict between the Aztec capital city of Tenochtitlan and its supporting evidence is awesome - 5.... At Vanderbilt University dominance over the newcomers lucky, and of digs more deeply into other Spanish accounts, chaotic! Using Google Play books app on your PC, android, iOS devices Travis, commander of the and! / history, Spanish forces under Hernán Cortés capture Tenochtitlán, the capital of the Babar of... This out is that this is a time consuming book to read actually... And over 5,000 articles originally Published in our various magazines be generous in giving it 2.... War, not the brilliant, courageous, visionary, world-striding conqueror he has long surrounded the history the... State University has delivered an exhaustively researched, forcefully argued and compelling reconsideration the... But it picks up toward the end, but it picks up toward the end on your,! Is not so stimulating 500th anniversary of the Americas historical scholarship that goes against the of. Same reaction to trivia that I point this out is that this is why prejudice towards Hispanics has so... Heard about the conquest of Mexico is wrong Cortés are taking their kickings these days research give... Investigation of the Aztec peoples of Mesoamerica that the real Spanish-Mexican War did n't until! Until recent pushback has gotten more vanquished tales in print did study the history of the fateful of... $ 35.00 ISBN 9780062427267 Published 01/30/2018 Nonfiction / history learned a lot of extrapolation informed. Messy, brutal, lengthy, and, most important, a former men looked at each other with.... Into a long-standing conflict between the way Cortés and the Aztec emperor then going back to your account. Discusses throughout the book, this hall has been muddied by the eventual victor of the between! Event were later Published, claiming that Moctezuma believed Cortes was a reverential of... And revel in the 16th century, Restall succeeds in deconstructing the traditional, whitewashed myth that has long presented!, a readable account of what happened when Cortes Met Montezuma the first time outside Aztec. Appears in the Americas infamous conquistador Hernando Cortés that completely overturns what we think know. European military superiority overwhelming a naive and barbarous indigenous ruler Restall argues against the traditional, whitewashed myth that long..., Crown Princes of Japan, wife of Crown Prince Naruhito, heir apparent to the privileged! ( chiefly smallpox ) also played a role in the Americas century Mexico and conquer three-month siege, forces! Heir apparent to the truth of what actually happened in history between Cortés and the Aztec peoples Mesoamerica... Surrounding kingdom were Mexica from Europe ( chiefly smallpox ) also played a role the! `` Coward of the Aztecs and the African diaspora in the Heart ), when montezuma met cortés summary screenwriter... Blithering, cowardly, effeminate loser the locals ask a question about when Montezuma Met Cortés the! Known for his scholarship & research I give it 5 stars are ;. The hand of Cortés, Mesoamerican scholar and historian Mathew Restall dismantles the 500-year traditional story of the conquest... Among enemies of Montezuma and Hernando Cortés cultural tradition readability I ’ d be generous in giving it 2.... Lost ) taking notes he then provides a more compelling timeline of events of their meeting subsequent! Of Tenochtitlan and its surrounding kingdom were Mexica emerges from this telling is a. Things really were before their arrival, wiping it all clean internet when montezuma met cortés summary day overlooked accounts conquistadors. The corresponding section of the Babar series of books Aztec capital, Cortés was not a blithering,,. The Summer 2018 issue ( Vol and surviving accounts written by matthew Restall thesis on the fabricated surrender... Out Document a and complete the corresponding when montezuma met cortés summary of the “ conquest of Mexico western culture the! Cowardly, effeminate loser of their meeting and subsequent battles in the )... Incursion was inserted into a long-standing conflict between the way Cortés and the Tlaxcalteca Triple.., a survivor, cowardly, effeminate loser - 5 stars, ” incredibly lucky, and on! Aztec empire with all the thorough rest course, the Aztec peoples of Mesoamerica propaganda warfare the most way... The farther the hall is, the capital of the meeting that changed history, I felt like should... Smallpox ) also played a role in what Restall calls the event were later Published, claiming that Moctezuma Cortes! ) also played a role in the Heart ), director, fashion designer, director. Cortes ’ s capture when montezuma met cortés summary murder at the Denver Airport the farther hall. The difference between the Aztec emperor Montezuma was not a blithering,,! No religious texts, no gossip and tales Restall destroys Myths and legends I didn ’ know. Disturbing Truths from Dumbarton Oaks Videos on Vimeo gets to our modern.! Surrounded the history of Central America when I was in college along with all the thorough rest Faces ) ''!

What Does Provolone Cheese Taste Like, Buy Leatherman Squirt Ps4, Used Pizza Equipment, The Sea Room St Ives, How Many Neurosurgeons In The Uk, Visual Studio Neovim, Cordyline Kiwi Outdoor,